Two Worlds

A blog about UK housing, Latin America, migration and the environment

  • Home
  • About
  • Masaya projects
  • Housing and migration publications
  • Contact
You are here: Home > Housing > Book Review: After Council Housing: Britain’s New Social Landlords by Hal Pawson and David Mullins

Book Review: After Council Housing: Britain’s New Social Landlords by Hal Pawson and David Mullins

November 24, 2010

after council

Was stock transfer a good idea? The odd thing about the question is that those answering ‘no’ straddle the political spectrum.  Of course, Defend Council Housing has been opposing stock transfer since it was set up thirteen years ago when Labour was first elected. It was affronted that the new government not only continued but accelerated the transfer programme: the next five years saw the peak of transfer activity.  But just recently the right-of-centre think tank Policy Exchange came out against it too. They argued for stock transfers to be brought back into public ownership, along with their £41bn estimated debt, because stock transfer housing associations have ‘failed to achieve their goals’.

So a dispassionate look at the reality of more than two decades of transfer is very welcome, and here we have it in a book by two experts in the field, Hal Pawson and Dave Mullins.  Usefully, the book straddles the whole of Great Britain, so is able to take account both of the early Scottish transfer experience, the massive change that took place in Glasgow seven years ago and the recent move towards mutual-based transfers in Wales.

Although there were earlier small scale transfers, by common consent the story began with the Chiltern transfer in 1988.  It is difficult now to remember that at the time a quarter of the population still lived in council housing. For every home owned by a housing association, thirteen were owned by councils, even after the loss of properties from the first years of right to buy.  Chiltern Council began a process that was to see associations become the majority social landlords only two decades later. Add in the growth of ALMOs after 2001, and now only one household in twenty lives in a home managed by their local authority. And most of this change took place under a Labour government.

Did this bottom-up revolution deliver better housing and more accountable  housing services?  Not surprisingly, the authors conclude that the picture is mixed. Transfer and ALMOs have delivered a massive improvement in stock condition, given massive stimulus by the decent homes target set in April, 2000.  Tenants now consistently say that they are more satisfied with their housing than before.

But the author’s argument that transfer could hardly be described as contributing to ‘choice’ is surely correct: it was the choice of those stuck between a rock and a hard place, and once the ballot was won not all landlords subsequently paid much attention to empowering tenants.  There are exceptions of course. Some urban transfers led to new associations that developed their engagement with residents and have maintained a strong community base.  More recently, we have seen a limited number of ‘community gateway’ transfers and five ‘community mutuals’ established in Wales.  But overall, the hopes of creating locally-based landlords that involve tenants at all levels of their governance were delivered on a bigger scale by ALMOs than by the mass of stock transfers.

If right to buy was the biggest change to affect social housing in Britain and was of course instigated by government, it remains an oddity that the second biggest change – stock transfer – was essentially led from below.  Governments caught up, of course – not just in Westminster but in Edinburgh and Cardiff.  But without those councillors and officers in a small district in Buckinghamshire taking a brave decision 22 years ago, it might never have happened.

Original post: Housing Magazine

 

Category: Housing | Tags: ALMOs, housing policy, stock transfer

« Previous Next »

Subscribe

Subscribe to the Two Worlds blog and we'll send you an email alert when we publish a new post. Please review our Privacy Policy if you have any questions or concerns.

Categories

  • Housing
  • Migration
  • Latin America
  • Masaya project updates
  • Energy and the environment
  • Central America wildlife
  • Book reviews
  • Obituaries

Tags

allocations ALMOs Amazon river Argentina armadillos asylum beds in sheds Berta Cáceres birds Bolivar borrowing rules Brazil budget butterflies caribbean census chile climate change Colombia community cohesion coronavirus Costa Rica council housing Cuba daily life destitution dictators drugs economics Ecuador El Salvador energy efficiency env environment Green Deal Guatemala Gypsies and Travellers Haiti homelessness homeownership Honduras housing housing associations housing benefit housing finance housing i housing investment housing market housing policy human rights iguanas immigration checks India inequality integration interoceanic canal investment Ireland Latin America Latin writers local authorities Malvinas Masaya media Mexico migration migration policy migration statistics mining model cities Nicaragua Nicaragua crisis Northern Ireland outsourcing panama Paraguay pension funds planning private rented sector public transport race refugees regeneration rents right to buy right to rent Scotland sloths slums solar energy Spain Spanish conquest stock transfer tenancy reform tenant involvement transport US intervention Venezuela Vista Alegre volcanoes welfare reform

Blogroll

  • Blogs for the London Review of Books
  • Articles for The Guardian
  • Blogs for Open Democracy
  • Blogs for Council on Hemispheric Affairs
  • Articles for Counterpunch
  • Articles for The Grayzone

Related websites

  • Chartered Institute of Housing
  • Housing Rights
  • Leicester Masaya Link Group
  • Council on Hemispheric Affairs
  • UK Housing Review
Housing Guardian contributor

Admin

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
John Perry John Perry lives in Masaya, Nicaragua where he works on
UK housing and migration issues and writes about those
and other topics covered in this blog.
Copyright © 2012- Two Worlds. Privacy & Cookie Policy. Powered by WordPress and Hybrid.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.AgreePrivacy & Cookie Policy