Two Worlds

A blog about UK housing, Latin America, migration and the environment

  • Home
  • Housing
  • Migration
  • Housing and migration publications
  • About
  • Contact
You are here: Home > Latin America > Islanders’ rights

Islanders’ rights

April 3, 2012

Map of the Malvinas, Falkland Islands

Britain remains staunchly committed to upholding the right of the Falkland Islanders, and of the Falkland Islanders alone, to determine their own future. That was the fundamental principle that was at stake 30 years ago: and that is the principle which we solemnly reaffirm today.

David Cameron’s speech marking the thirtieth anniversary of the conflict over the Malvinas islands reiterates a ‘fundamental principle’ that is not only inapplicable in the case of the Malvinas but is conveniently ignored elsewhere if Britain’s strategic interests require it. The principle of self-determination is well established, but is meant to apply to longstanding inhabitants of a colonised territory. The current inhabitants of the Malvinas arrived after Britain captured the islands from a recently independent Argentina in 1833. The British attack was effectively an act of piracy in a part of the world where piracy was commonly practised by Spain as well as Britain, but the fact that it was commonplace does not make it legitimate. Indeed, Britain had promised not to do any such thing when it signed the Treaty of San Lorenzo with Spain in 1790.

In 2006, yet another UN resolution called for talks between Britain and Argentina over the islands. Before the Special Committee on Decolonisation, the islanders argued for self-determination and against colonisation. The Argentinians explained the history of their administration of the islands before 1833, argued that the current islanders are not a ‘people’ in the sense intended by the principle of self-determination, and furthermore that many thousands of British people have successfully been absorbed into Argentina since independence in 1816 (the Welsh in Patagonia are perhaps the best-known example). A succession of Latin American governments supported Argentina’s position, but Britain didn’t bother to back the islanders’ case.

An illuminating contrast has occasionally been pointed out between the Malvinas and Britain’s leasing out of the island of Diego Garcia in the 1960s to create a US airbase. This resulted in the expulsion of the Chagos islanders, who were without question denied the right of self-determination. (Is this what Cameron meant when he said it was the right ‘of the Falkland Islanders alone’?) The British High Court and Court of Appeal found in the favour of islanders suing for right of abode in the Chagos, but their judgments were overturned by the House of Lords in 2008. In 2010 the Labour government made the seas around the Chagos archipelago into a marine reserve. According to a cable from the US embassy in London published by WikiLeaks:

Establishing a marine reserve might, indeed, as the FCO’s Roberts stated, be the most effective long-term way to prevent any of the Chagos Islands’ former inhabitants or their descendants from resettling.

As in Diego Garcia, Britain’s actions in the Malvinas are based on its strategic interests, but in the South Atlantic the public-spirited protection of the islands’ inhabitants offers a convenient smokescreen.

Original post and comments: London Review of Books

Category: Latin America | Tags: Argentina, Malvinas

« Previous Next »

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Subscribe to the Two Worlds blog and we'll send you an email alert when we publish a new post. Please review our Privacy Policy if you have any questions or concerns.

Check your inbox now to confirm your subscription.

Categories

  • Housing
  • Migration
  • Latin America
  • Masaya project updates
  • Energy and the environment
  • Central America wildlife
  • Book reviews
  • Obituaries
  • Uncategorized

Tags

allocations ALMOs Amazon river Argentina armadillos asylum beds in sheds Berta Cáceres birds Bolivar borrowing rules Bosawás Brazil budget butterflies caribbean census chile climate change Colombia community cohesion coronavirus Costa Rica council housing Covid-19 Cuba daily life destitution dictators drugs economics Ecuador El Salvador energy efficiency env environment Georgia Green Deal Guatemala Gypsies and Travellers Haiti homelessness homeownership hond Honduras housing housing associations housing benefit housing finance housing i housing investment housing market housing policy hum human rights iguanas immigration checks India Indigenous people inequality integration interoceanic canal investment Ireland Latin America Latin writers local authorities Malvinas Masaya media Mexico migration migration policy migration statistics mining model cities NGOs Nicaragua Nicaragua crisis Nicaraguan elections Northern Ireland outsourcing palestine panama Paraguay pension funds planning private rented sector public transport race refugees regeneration rents right to buy right to rent sanctions Scotland sloths slums solar energy Spain Spanish conquest stock transfer syria tenancy reform tenant involvement transport ukraine US intervention Venezuela Vista Alegre volcanoes welfare reform

Blogroll

  • Blogs for the London Review of Books
  • Articles for The Guardian
  • Blogs for Open Democracy
  • Blogs for Council on Hemispheric Affairs
  • Articles for Counterpunch
  • Articles for The Grayzone
  • Articles for NACLA
  • Posts for Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
  • Articles for Global Research
  • Articles for LA Progressive
  • Two Worlds on Substack
  • Articles for Covert Action Magazine
  • Articles for Black Agenda Report
  • Articles for Antiwar.com
  • Articles for Monthly Review online

Related websites

  • Chartered Institute of Housing
  • Housing Rights
  • Council on Hemispheric Affairs
  • UK Housing Review
  • Nicaragua Solidarity Coalition
Housing Guardian contributor
John Perry John Perry lives in Masaya, Nicaragua where he works on
UK housing and migration issues and writes about those
and other topics covered in this blog.
Copyright © 2012- Two Worlds. Privacy & Cookie Policy. Powered by WordPress.